| Last week, a man with two children walking to work to his job as a steamfitter at the Metropolitan Museum of Art was struck by a bicycle in Central Park and killed. Along the same lines, here are two other terrible headlines taken from the Gothamist in the last 10 days: “Dump truck driver hits and kills cyclist in Midtown” and “15-year-old dead after truck hits two teens in East Village.” These horrible accidents are becoming so commonplace, we are no longer surprised to read them. |
| Now here’s a third headline from the Gothamist from a month ago: “Blood on the streets. Mamdani has a vision zero crisis”. Importantly, this headline was not written by a tabloid looking for attention; this is the website put out by WNYC public radio which is preternaturally calming. |
| For pedestrians, the streets have become an obstacle course to navigate with vigilance and care. Bicyclists of all kinds now take their own lives in their hands while riding. For seniors whose mobility is limited, the situation is even worse. Attention must be paid as this chaotic situation on New York City’s streets is out of control. |
| Anecdotally, we know two people who ended up in the emergency room in the past year while riding their bikes. They are not reckless and pose no threat to anyone. It’s just that things happen with so much chaos on the streets. Even for a careful person, riding a bike just isn’t safe anymore. |
| The simple fact is that New York City is just too congested to safely accommodate trucks, taxis, Ubers, regular cars, e-bikes, regular bikes, e-scooters, regular scooters, and perhaps most importantly pedestrians. Most bicyclists do follow the rules, but that doesn’t matter as some don’t and speed through red lights, against traffic and on sidewalks. The fundamental problem is that the expansion of bicycle access – or micromobility as it is called – just doesn’t work here. Mayor Mamdani can put in more bike lanes he wants, which is fine but that’s not nearly enough. For pedestrians, every day is an urban nightmare having to dodge speeding delivery people and bikes. |
| However, Mamdani is well known as a supporter of cycling even though bicyclists beat the brunt of the injuries and deaths. When criticized regarding his political ideology as he was getting on a Citibike, he whimsically responded, “I’m a cyclist, not a communist”. |
| Tragically, the condition of our streets is no joke. Here’s a statistic that shocked me from the website of the firm AEE Law which conducted a full review of 2.27 million NYPD collision records. Since 2019, e-bike-involved crashes in New York City injured 17,434 people and killed 133, including both pedestrians and riders. Pedestrians account for 1547 of the injured and 16 of the dead while riders themselves absorb most of the harm. Despite these jaw-dropping statistics, the city ended criminal enforcement for e-bike offenses on March 27. |
| Accordingly, this is a problem that needs to be solved now and just can’t wait. I recognize that some of our friends and clients enjoy riding bikes for the convenience of Citibikes and the like, but looking at the situation from 30,000 feet the negatives of bicycle expansion far outweigh the positives. |
| After a head-on collision between an e-scooter and a bicyclist in which both were killed on the Queensboro Bridge, New York state senator Kristen Gonzalez, and assembly member Diane Moreno introduced a bill two weeks ago that would prohibit retailers from selling e-bikes or scooters capable of exceeding 20 mph, with civil penalties reaching $1000 for every prohibited sale. This will of course be opposed by the delivery companies whose drivers represent a huge percentage of the bicyclists. Most delivery people follow rules, but they are under heavy time and financial pressures. Underscoring that point, Doordash just settled a lawsuit with New York City alleging underpayment of its employees by agreeing to pay $131 million to 264,000 delivery workers. |
| In mid-September, the mayor put forward his latest street safety plan called “Vision Zero Reimagined“ which is designed to limit traffic deaths and injuries, which include creating pedestrian only areas, reducing the speed limit for cars, improving 1000 intersections, and expanding street safety projects. These changes are fine, but they’re also like putting a Band-Aid on your head when brain surgery is needed. |
| The mayor also recently changed his ways and performatively donned a helmet for his bicycle rides to model better riding behavior but that is just basic common sense. As an analogy, can anyone imagine a hockey player playing without a helmet these days? Years ago, almost none of the players wore helmets either. |
| Unfortunately, Vision Zero has lost the plot here. It has no teeth. There are no criminal penalties to discourage bad behavior by cyclists, and no enforcement improvements. So what is the point of the whole exercise? |
| You might ask why I am banging on about something that on the surface has nothing to do with office space. The answer is because it has a lot to do with the quality of life in New York, which is directly related to the question of whether people want to live and work here. Crime is very much under control, but the traffic chaos is not. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch is cracking down on quality-of-life crimes, but in my view the daily street disorder poses a greater danger to those of us who are out and about every day (it’s also why Eric won’t leave our apartment except for important meetings and ballgames).
|
| Anyone who has driven on a New York City street can see one major problem. Most of the bike lanes are on the left side of the street. When a driver makes a left turn with a car, they are turning into the lane of bicyclists that are going straight. This is an obvious collision course, and, and is particularly dangerous, and those terms are particularly dangerous at night in areas which are not well lit. Even the most careful driver can make a mistake in judging the speed of the oncoming bicycles or of a pedestrian unexpectedly entered the crosswalk. |
| The only way to fix this is to have dedicated bike lanes on every side street off a main avenue so that cars and bicycles never come into contact with each other. Unfortunately, that is impossible. |
| Accordingly, City Hall needs to understand that this misbegotten experiment will never work here. In the meantime, countless pedestrians and cyclists are swept up into this vortex of chaos leading to thousands of debilitating injuries a year, not to mention double-digit deaths. Of course, that doesn’t even take into account the near misses we have all experienced which are astronomical. It’s time that we wake up and realize that the expansion of bicycling, while convenient for a few, does not justify the urban carnage that it is wreaking in NYC. |
| We shouldn’t despair as there are some very easy solutions to this problem. Here are 6 off the top of my head, and I’m sure there are more. This is just a starting point.
|
|
| 1) E-bikes and e-scooters should be banned in New York City. |
|
|
|
|
| 2) There should be strict speed limits of 15 miles an hour for all bicycles. |
|
|
|
|
| 3) All delivery workers using bicycles should be licensed and they should be required to take a safety class. |
|
|
|
|
| 4) The police should start enforcing speed limits more vigorously for both cars and bicycles. |
|
|
|
|
| 5) Driving a bicycle while impaired should be a potential criminal offense just like driving a car while impaired. |
|
|
|
|
| 6) Children under 18 should be forbidden from riding on city streets as a comparable level of skill in driving a car is required to ride a bicycle under such dangerous conditions. |
|
|
|
|
This may seem a bit heavy-handed, but these horrendous accidents are easily avoidable. And what about the level of alertness that that all pedestrians need to have when walking the streets? People are looking at their phones or focused on what they are listening to on their earphones, but one wrong move and their lives can be forever changed. All of this is totally unnecessary. |
| We all get distracted while reading our phones were thinking about a million things. One loss of concentration and you can be dead or grievously injured. This makes no sense. There is a group called “Transportation Alternatives” that supposedly advocates for safe bicycling in the city. Sadly, it appears it is more interested in getting more access for bikes than it is in civic safety that would require stringent new regulations. |
| Mayor Mamdani is a believer in the power of the people. Well, we shouldn’t be taking our lives in our hands every time we set foot outside. That may sound like hyperbole, but it is where we are now. As a result, it’s up to us to reimagine a safer city as it’s long past time to take our streets back and institute a real common sense safety plan that protects pedestrians and bike riders alike without delay. There’s not a moment to waste. |
Thank you,
Ruth Colp-Haber |