Last week, Governor Hochul announced that she had reached an agreement with Mayor Mamdani on the pied-a-terre tax on unoccupied second residences worth over $5 million in New York City. The tax was estimated to generate $500 million in annual revenue. Afterward, the mayor released a video gloating over the tax and physically pointing to the $238 million apartment of Citadel CEO Ken Griffin as justification.
In our recent newsletter, I pointed out the obvious analogy to the Amazon fiasco in which that company pulled the plug on an important NYC project, and suggesting that the mayor’s ill-advised remarks personalizing the tax would not end well. It was all too predictable.
Griffin is understandably displeased and is scheduled to meet with Governor Hochul tomorrow to discuss the state’s “future direction”. At a conference in Oslo, Norway yesterday, Griffin reportedly said that “I think the willingness of a mayor of New York to make this policy debate a personal attack just demonstrated a profound lack of judgment.”
Tomorrow’s meeting between the governor and the CEO should be quite something. Below is a fictional version of the conversation that might take place at that meeting:
Governor Hochul: “Ken, it’s always a pleasure to see you. What can I do for you today?”
Ken Griffin: “You know why I’m here. What your boy the mayor said was not very nice. After all, my company was planning to spend $6 billion on a new skyscraper at 350 Park Avenue. Do you know how many thousands of jobs that’s going to create for the city? Try over 15,000, plus the construction jobs while we’re building it.”
Governor: “I know, I know. These young kids, they’re very excitable. But he means well.”
Griffin: “I’m not sure about that. And I’m sure you also know because you read my COO’s memo that Citadel’s employees paid almost $2.3 billion worth of city and state taxes in the past five years and I have personally given over $600 million to NYC charitable institutions. That pays for a lot of child care, among other things.”
Hochul: “I’m well aware of that as well. And that’s why we’re going to give a carve out to you as part of an exemption to the tax for people who create over 100 jobs in New York City. I’ll take care of it. There’s a reason we didn’t provide any of the fine details when we announced the pied-a-terre tax.”
Griffin: “That’s fine, but the damage is done. It seems we’re not welcome here. You see there’s a city called Miami that I know you’re familiar with. They’re very happy to have us there, and we don’t have to pay any taxes either. New York is great, and we were looking forward to expanding here. You’ve got a brilliant and vibrant business community, it’s one of the safest cities in the country and my people like living here. And we pay them so well they can even afford your private schools.”
“But I expect you’ve studied Citadel’s record in Chicago, and you saw what happened when I didn’t get along with Governor Pritzker and we left the city because of the taxes and crime. Let’s just say that disrespect isn’t something that I take to kindly.”
“So I tell you what we’re going to do. First, we’re going to move some of our Citadel jobs down to Miami and expand our real estate footprint there. Next, we’re going to reconsider whether to go forward with the new building. That’s a little more complicated because we (Citadel) purchased a controlling 60% position from Vornado and Rudin in February, but my lawyers are looking at the contracts now. Then we’ll see what happens.”
Governor: “Say it ain’t Zo! I’ve got a headache, literally and politically. Let’s stay in touch.”
Thank you,
Ruth Colp-Haber
