
“I’ve become the therapist in chief it seems.”
New York State Governor Kathy Hochul
The first half of 2025 showed a significant uptick in office leasing in New York City. Tenants took almost 21 million square feet in the first six months of this year, which was the highest total since 2014. In fact, New York is going the opposite direction to the rest of the United States where office vacancy is up to 20.6% as compared to 17% five years ago. However, the bifurcated market reared up again locally as the Commercial Observer reported that in NYC tech firms and tenants in other than Class A are taking shorter and smaller leases due to economic uncertainty and AI.
Just when we might have started to become complacent, there is no ignoring the recent victory of Zohran Mamdani in the Democratic mayoral primary that is worrying business leaders. No one can predict with certainty what the impact will be if he becomes mayor, and it needs to be emphasized that taxes for New York City are determined by the New York State legislature and the governor. Indeed, Governor Hochul said this morning on “Morning Joe” that she has acting as the “therapist in chief” for the many businesspeople who have called to express concern and some of whom are threatening to leave New York if Mamdani is elected mayor.
Residential developer Miki Naftali had an interesting take in Bisnow regarding potential wealth migration to Miami when he said that “New York is booming.” He further observed, “When you look at what happened with Covid, so people left [New York], and what happened? Other people came, because New York is New York. And the same: Miami is Miami,” … I think that we need to stop comparing Miami to New York or New York to Miami. This is not a competition.”
I think Naftali is half-right. There is no comparison between the two cities because New York City’s economy is the largest of any metropolitan area in the United States, with $2 trillion in gross metropolitan product, representing 9% of the total United States economy and 5 times larger than the Miami economy. Further, notwithstanding all the unfair criticism we have received, New York City continues to lead in attracting talented young people, with nearly 500,000 recent college graduates choosing to live here since 2021 according to the NYC Economic Development Commission, which doesn’t include countless other relatively young professionals who have moved to the city during that period as well.
Where I differ with Naftali is that it is a competition as every other city and state is trying to steal New York’s business. For example, Texas is forming its own stock exchange. And just last week, Florida eliminated its 2% business rent tax. In contrast, New York has a commercial rent tax on 3.9% of commercial rents below 96th Street with an annual rent over $250,000.
Indeed, a couple of Mamdani’s ideas may be worth trying. For example, perhaps the MTA could use some of the anticipated $500 million in additional revenue from congestion pricing this year for a pilot program with discounted transit fares for seniors, children, and people below a certain income level. In addition, while I’m no expert in childcare we also know that the free pre-K program has been a success and that children with early education have better outcomes.
However, Mamdani is way off target on the big Kahuna which is his proposed rent freeze on rent-stabilized apartments. That key issue was crystallized by the latest rental statistics. Manhattan’s median rent was $4,625 last month, representing the fourth time in the past five months that the figure set a record and amounting to a $55,500 average per year tenants must shell out after taxes. In Brooklyn and northwest Queens, the median rents are $3,650 and $3,625 respectively. Small wonder that many of the new arrivals and longer-term residents who are forced to live in involuntary roommate situations or expensive rentals are unhappy with the high cost of their housing.
But here’s the paradox of the proposed Mamdani rent freeze. It would only pertain to the rent on the 1 million rent stabilized apartments, even though some people may incorrectly think it applies to all apartments in NYC. However, the freeze would have no impact whatsoever on everyone else (other than creating a shortage of supply and reducing the ability of some landlords to perform necessary upkeep). Nevertheless, it was the young and well-educated professionals from 18 to 44 that constitute a high percentage of the recent arrivals noted above that also provided Mamdani’s highest voting margins. I’m not sure that they appreciate that a freeze in the much lower rent-stabilized rents won’t help them one bit, because rent stabilization ends when the current tenant leaves or dies.
Further, none of the commentary I have seen has noted the extremely small rate of increase in rent-stabilized apartments for the last 10 years. Research by our crack staff reveals that even after the most recent 3% annual hike for 2025-2026 is factored in, the total rent increase in rent-stabilized apartments over the last 10 years was a total of just 15% for one-year lease extensions, well below the rate of both inflation and wage growth. That amounts to a de minimis average of 1.5% a year for rent stabilized apartments since 2015 – which is effectively a rent freeze in the real world. It also explains why so many savvy tenants keep their rent-stabilized apartments for decades as a de facto life estate. Indeed, in some instances that estate extends through several generations if they follow the rules for family succession as many do in Eric’s native Stuyvesant Town and Peter Cooper Village where the free market rents can be 3 and 4 times the regulated rents after apartments ultimately do turn over.
Something doesn’t add up here. Everyone who has the good fortune to live in a rent-stabilized apartment should be thrilled that they have been spared from the uncertainty of living without rent protection. Further, they should give thanks for all the New York State legislators and the nine governors of both parties who maintained the rent stabilization law when it has come up for renewal periodically since 1969 despite vigorous landlord opposition, including Governor Pataki for 12 years and Governors Mario and Andrew Cuomo for a combined 22 more years.
Shifting gears to office leasing, which is our line of business, some facts are beyond political dispute. Opportunities for the bargain office seeker continue to arise and surprise in our completely unregulated and opaque market where the counsel of an experienced professional advisor’s assistance is essential. The average asking rent for commercial space is under $74 per square foot, with sublets trading at 25% or more below that amount. Don’t miss out on the significant savings from the bargains that remain available in all but the trophy buildings. We can help you separate the wheat from the chaff.
Please click here in order to schedule a time to speak with our CEO Ruth Colp-Haber
