Thanks to the platform Flex Index, I recently learned about an interesting peer-reviewed study out of Singapore regarding remote work, which continues to be a subject of robust debate in both the real estate and corporate community. A survey of managers found that they believed that workers who used flexible working arrangements were less productive, motivated, and committed than their colleagues who work in the office full-time. The managers not only held this view of employees who worked remotely every day, but also those who worked remotely only two or three times a week.

Heejung Chung of King’s College, London, and Senhu Wang of the University of Singapore found that despite the steep rise in working from home practices around the world, stigmatized views against remote workers still exist. Second, negative managerial attitudes were more pronounced for fathers and childless workers who chose to work at home. This is a change from the Covid years when remote work was necessity.

The study also confirmed what I have learned anecdotally in my discussions with business leaders in the post-pandemic period. Managers tend to value employees whom they see in person regularly more than those who work mostly remotely.

Further, the managers’ views also extend to situations when there is a personnel layoff. The same executives have told me that when forced to decide which employees to keep and which to let go, the people that they see regularly have an advantage over those they don’t know as well when they have to make difficult staffing decisions. All things being equal, it’s human nature to give a break to people you know, unlike as compared to people you don’t know at all. Real life face time matters.

Coincidentally, a recent article in the Financial Times by Ellesheva Kissin reported that executives at some of the UK’s largest consulting firms will be asking junior staff back to the office. The reason is because they need to improve their “human skills“ as artificial intelligence will be taking over a growing proportion of their technical work. As a result, interpersonal skills have become more valuable than ever, and managers believe they must be developed in the office – with other people around.

Unfortunately, many of us have become somewhat detached from each other due to both improved technology and the pandemic. As a result, for many workers basic people skills have ossified. That is true as well in businesses that provide counsel and advice of all kinds to their clients. However, companies are noticing and taking action. As an example, KPMG is trying new approaches to in-person training to “reinvent“ the way it helps their staff build their “soft skills “as well as technical skills.

Said another way, people with a high level of computer and mathematical expertise are going to have to learn to deal with other humans better because AI can do their technical work. Otherwise, they will be surplus to requirements. If you don’t believe me, you can read the recent essay by Bill Gates, who is extremely concerned about the unemployment problem that AI may create and also advocates a “token tax“ on AI use to help deal with the dislocation he expects it will cause.

The FT article also reflects a shift in thinking across white-collar industries. After dealing with the inconvenience of remote work for a half a decade or more, many employers have concluded that technology has made in-person collaboration even more essential in the age of artificial intelligence.

How significant is this change in attitudes? The Wall Street Journal reported yesterday that E&Y will be giving $100 million in bonuses to employees who demonstrate human skills like adaptability, innovation, and judgment, as well as experimentation with AI. It also noted that earlier this year PwC launched a learning program with the goal of emphasizing both AI skills and human traits, such as empathy and creativity.

That’s a polite way of describing the problem faced by employers. In a recent article, Amanda Hoover of Business Insider bluntly asserts that businesses are begging colleges to help Gen Z learn how to talk.

To be fair, the counterargument by the work from home crowd led by Stanford professor Nick Bloom is that if a company cannot accommodate flexible working arrangements, it is the result of a failure of leadership that is unwilling to adapt to modern times. I think that may be a little harsh given the extraordinary flexibility shown by business, which adjusted incredibly well to a worldwide plague which would have been unimaginable to anyone except epidemiologists and Hollywood scriptwriters.

So what does this mean to you? Well, it’s very simple. If you’re young or even mid-career, get yourself to the office if you ever want to advance. You might even learn something from someone while you’re there. Second, we all need to learn how to talk to other people using something other than a screen. Otherwise you’re not much of an improvement over agentic AI. Third, your regular physical presence at the office might save your job someday, regardless of your level of seniority.

Now that doesn’t mean there’s not a place for remote work, particularly with long-term employees. For example, we at Wharton Property Advisors have several employees with physical challenges or special family situations that require individualized handling and remote work accommodation. That is good for business and also the right thing to do.

And then there’s that scoundrel Eric. He steadfastly refuses to come to the office except for important meetings, but what am I to do with him? He knows I won’t fire him, and yes, he’s very smart, moderately hard-working and helps bring in the clients. I guess I’ll have to keep him around.

Whatever your company’s working or family setup, Wharton Property Advisors can help you find an office space that meet your needs. Please feel free to contact us to tap our expertise. We always represent our clients with integrity, creativity, intelligence, and diligence.

Thank you,
Ruth Colp-Haber